I am not a ya fan particulary since the first ones i read was horrible,then i read another one and it was pretty good,well this book was ok..better than teh first one i read but not as good as last one. I have very little patience with a whiner ,Ever wasn't whiny to begin but then she became a whiner then she was ok. This book was hard for me to get through without putting it down saying I am done. I am glad I read it but not so sure if I will read the next one in line. The story was ok but not a page turner.